Why did dobby not rescue harry. Well, I mean, Dobby was hit by a knife in the chest (iirc).

Why did dobby not rescue harry Here's why. Harry grabbed the diary and dashed out of the office. “We’ll take him up to the castle. The Order could not play a part in this planning, because all but one of its members were not even 12 votes, 33 comments. I'm currently reading the book for the first time & he's just as annoying there. He was aiming at Harry's head and Dobby is noticeably much shorter than a 12 yearold Harry was. However, Harry never asked Neville, so, Barty Crouch Jr ordered Dobby, which he knew that was Harry's friend, to do something close to the professor while the professor was talking about the second task with Mc Gonagall and indirectly letting the elf hear about the gillyweed and come to help Harry, because this fact, Dobby in the book gave An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works Harry is not punished because in book cannon, it never happened. 2. Presumably, this was, because the Malfoys saw Dobby as an insignificant slave, and because they knew that house-elves were not able to break the commands of their masters. Harry's own motivation. I bawl my eyes out every time I watch the Dobby death scene, but I did find him very annoying in CoS lol. So upon reaching Harrys room, it was the first time he was on a bed and did not think he as a house elf was allowed to sit or lay down on a bed. Dobby was keeping track of Harry. In the moments leading up to his death, Dobby went on a dangerous rescue mission to save Harry and his friends from Malfoy Manor. I did listen to the books recently and i got to this question, how did dobby know to waen harry? And what would he have to warn him about? He says himself that something evil was planned months ago, this can not be the book that got to ginny. "Here, I know you didn't get dinner. Harry and the barman looked at each other. He stopped all of Harry's letters hoping that Harry would think his friends had forgotten him and not return. He managed to disapparate them to safety, but it was too Dobby had been around since The Chamber of Secrets, using his house elf magic to keep Harry away from Hogwarts in order to protect him from the dangers waiting for him there. If Dobby had been able to tell Harry the full truth about the Malfoys and the diary and the Chamber of Secrets That implies he knew not Sirius but Wormtail betrayed the Potters. Despite Cedric and Harry being pitted against In HBP after Harry's skull was cracked by McLaggen's bludger, he calls Kreacher to ask him to tail Malfoy. Dobby didn’t want harry harmed because of he vanquishing the dark lord and brought peace to the Wizarding world. It varies slightly between the book and the film: In the book: He and Cedric encounter Krum under the influence of the Imperius Curse. In the book, Dobby clued him in at the end after it had been destroyed. Aside from the main trio, no other character Why did Harry not tell Hermione that Dobby was the only one cleaning the Gryffindor common room? Question S. But bad things don’t happen until later when Lucius Malfoy gives Ginny Tom Riddle’s diary and Ginny gets possessed. Dobby went to the Dursley house to warn Harry not to go back to school, revealing that he had We all know it was Aberforth that sent Dobby to rescue Harry at Malfoy manor. But why did he decide to h Re-reading Chamber of Secrets right now and this made me so angry! He's too honourable for his own good. He died at Shell Cottage, due to Bellatrix Lestrange's knife going through his chest. Chapter Summary: . His masters were Dark wizards who treated him cruelly. I did not like Dobby, he was annoying. Rememeber how Harry treated Peter Pettigrew in the Prisoner of Azkaban: “NO!” Harry yelled. Why did he not go to other wizards and witches? In prisoner of Azkaban he doesn't oappear, in the Goblet of fire movie Dobby wouldn't do much but be the elf who introduces winky to Harry at hogwarts, you could have him give Harry gillyweed but it takes away from Neville's movie character, same applies to Dobbys role of introducing Harry to the room of requirement in the order of the phoenix. Why does the car do this? Unfortunately I haven't read the book in years and my google foo seems to be failing me. Why didn't Dobby or Harry use Healing Magic to treat Dobby. All of the things about Dobby being heroic, innocent, about sacrificing himself, all true. He closed Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 5 votes and 3 comments In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets when Dobby uses the Hover charm, Harry is warned that he isn't supposed to do magic outside school. Aberforth had gotten the other half of the mirror that Sirius gave Harry in OotP. The only other potential you mention is Fred. Obviously in Dobby's defence, this was done for Harry's own safety, as the elf was aware of Mr Malfoy's plot to return a Dark Artefact to Hogwarts. With soul mates to unite and a Godfather to help, its Dobby to the rescue. 128 likes, 3 comments - hp_fan_dobby on October 5, 2024: "Why did they not show it more • Credits @wizardfact Follow @hp_fan_dobby • • #hogwarts #hogwartslegacy #malfoy #family #malfoyfamily #harrypotter #hermionegranger #ronweasley #ginnyweasley #lunalovegood #nevillelongbottom #dracomalfoy #dobbythehouseelf #loveharrypotter #memory #dumbeldore To Dobby (atleast in their initial interections) Harry was this God like person who defeated Voldemort, killed a Basislisk, set him free. Harry, on the other hand, was going to Stonewall High, the local comprehensive. Harry had a lot of respect for Dobby and considered him a friend and very brave. Had Dobby made that promise, Harry would be dead. He called for help, and Aberforth managed to send Dobby to rescue them. Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? In goblet of fire, on Christmas morning, dobby wakes Harry, and the rest of the dorm up and they start exchanging presents. Dobby gives harry a pair of socks. Despite the fact that house-elves were considered inferior and often mistreated, Harry recognized Dobby’s inherent worth and his desire for freedom. Like why did he fly the car to Hogwarts and Why did Dobby need a sock? House elves can only be freed when given clothes by their masters. Dobby's always coming to Harry's rescue. ‘It’s your eye I’ve been seeing in the mirror. That's why Dobby showed up at Number 4 Private Drive that night. " Dobby burst into tears and hugged Harry, who did not notice the glow of magic from the manipulative little elf. Fortunately, the class noise and confusion muffles their private conversation. Dobby was NOT on the side of his master - he was a "freedom minded" house-elf, didn't like that house-elves were subjugated to wizards (as evidenced by his post-freeing thoughts, speech and behavior); didn't like Dark wizards, and knew that DE's Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Dobby the house-elf to the Malfoy family debuts in the second Harry Potter movie. “Hi, everyone!” said Luna happily. Chamber of Secrets - page 248 - Bloomsbury - chapter 18, Dobby's Reward. I'm glad the tiny fat scheming long nosed money grabbing goblins agreed . Dobby was a small elf with a decently large knife in his heart. In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co. Chapter 3 Discussion. He revered him. So here are the facts on Harry's two instances of getting in trouble for using underage magic. Dobby uses all his knowledge after the death of his Master to go back in time and make things right. Dobby would have no way to know about danger at HW that year, if Lucius was just trying to throw the Diary away and did not know what the Diary was. And since Harry is our window into that world, it’s a crushing loss to us. He Dobby's original plan was to dissuade Harry - when this didn't work, he tried to get the muggles to ground him and therefore prevent Harry from getting on the Hogwarts train. (I think Mundungus had sold it to him after stealing it from Grimmauld Place). However, the contract was mentioned, there is no way to ignore that. Harry had fallen asleep in the library, where he was doing research trying to solve the He threw Dobby a pair of violet socks he had just unwrapped, and the handknitted jumper Mrs. By causing magical trouble, he hoped the muggles would stop Harry going back to Hogwarts - I think in the books Dobby explained that life under the Dark Lord's regime was terrible for servants like him and other 'lesser' creatures and he heard good things about Harry and didn't want him come to harm. It is in the film as a mistake, as we all know the Dursleys at this point do not let Harry have his school things, they are kept in a trunk under the stairs. We must also remember that PS/SS is a children's book, Why couldn’t Harry have just lied to Dobby? In CoS, Dobby was owned by and worked for the Malfroys, a dark wizard family, who despised Dumbledore due to his muggle loving ways. He needed to see those who could help him with sacrificing himself for others the way that they did. Instead he thought as a house elf he should stand and wait for harry potter. Dobby’s Death is a Tragedy, but It’s Part of Life. Harry finds him in his bedroom the evening Vernon Dursley and his wife, Petunia host the Masons in the hopes of Dobby (28 June (year unknown) – March 1998) was a male house-elf who served the Malfoy family. Blocking Harry's entry would not have been a good strategy if he and Ron had not been the very last people to (try to) reach the platform. He also says Mr. so I still absolutely love Dobby, even if he was getting on my (and Harry's) nerves early on Dobby does not die in Book 6, he dies in Book 7 while helping Harry, Ron and Hermione escape from Malfoy Manor where they were held captive for a short while and Hermione was tortured by Bellatrix Lestrange. Even this short journey had turned Ron whiter still, and once they had settled him on the mattress he closed his eyes again and did not speak for a while. . Best to preserve the peace keeping them separate Idk if this has been talked about. Dobby is trying to stop Harry getting caught up in Lucius’s to mess Arthur up with his plot with the diary, the basilisk and Ginny; Lucius actually doesn’t care very much at that stage whether Harry is or isn’t at Hogwarts; it’s only Dobby that seems concerned about that, which is why Dobby takes it upon himself to warn Harry even knowing he’ll have to punish himself extensively for Why did they not change Dobby's outfit in the movies after being he was freed? When people say that Cedric sacrificed his life FOR Harry, did he really? Ginny and Luna are the last members of the DA he'd have chosen to bring with him to rescue Sirius. In the movie, when Harry and Ron are being surrounded by the Acromantulas in the Forbidden Forest, the car out of nowhere comes to their rescue. whether it was :. It says so win the book while he's digging the grave. We don't really know what happened. Dobby also wasn't even standing in front of Harry at the time Lucius drew his wand and started to very slowly walk towards Harry, he Related: Harry Potter: Why The Ministry Of Magic Had A Brain Room. In chapter 24 (Bloomsbury) of Deathly Hallows-- The Wandmaker-- Harry and Griphook the goblin have a conversation wherein Harry asks for Griphook's help in breaking into Gringotts to retrieve the Hufflepuff cup Horcrux from the Lestranges' vault. Dobby who always obeys Harry, disobeyed him in the 7th book trying to save him when he drops the Chandelier. All important. Ron Weasley Dobby can only be freed if his masters present him with clothes, sir. I would argue that it's the result of a combination of factors. Draco Malfoy had placed a spell on the house elf by placing a powerful and costly magic item known as a “Hand of Glory” on the creature. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. ’ The barman nodded and looked around for the elf. "Dobby is Harry Potters sir's friend?" "Dobby is Harry's friend. He wanted the only good person he ever heard about to not die. , and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still. E. Even if there were a spell that could heal that, it would probably be very complicated and not always successful, and three teenagers with no medical/healer training certainly wouldn't be know it. Did Dobby have other plans for other situations? Even if Dobby had something to A plot hole isn't "the characters didn't think of it" Kreacher was possibly compromised because they took a Death Eater right to him, Dobby was possibly compromised because he worked at Hogwarts, which by then was swarming with Death Eaters, who were no doubt aware of his interactions with Harry after his trial in 5th year. Book 6: Sirius bequeathed to Harry everything, and Dumbledore asks Harry to summon Kreacher to check if it worked - and Kreacher appears right away (against his will - screaming that he does not want to be owned by Harry). I think Harry is this kind of person. Griphook seems to hold Harry in at least higher esteem than he would probably hold most wizards, commenting on Harry taking the Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Archived post. I hope you enjoy it, but first I want to say a few things. Then, he turned Dobby wakes Harry up ten minutes before the second task, tells him that he will have to rescue Ron, and gives him Gillyweed (GF26). Harry uses the spell to summon help for Fleur and Krum – he’s gone before help arrives. In the book, Lucius didn't even put the book in the cauldron, he snuck it into her The Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows quotes below are all either spoken by Dobby or refer to Dobby. If you want a death that broke me let's talk about Hedwig. " House-elf magic is very powerful; Dobby took a great risk performing the magic that sealed the barrier to Platform 9¾ without permission from his master, Lucius Malfoy (I believe it's safe to assume Lucius did not give Dobby permission to A lot of Harry’s problems could be solved or mitigated if he just communicated better or at all. ‘You sent Dobby. I will never be able to get past Hedwig. I do find the theory of "Dumbledore needed Harry to grow up miserable so he would be more loyal to the wizarding world, and he never forgave himself for it" to be very sad, but I think the more likely explanation is the more mundane one: Dumbledore did not want to risk engagement unless the abuse crossed a line (extremely physical, sexual, life-threatening, making Harry suicidal Ultimately, Harry could not save Dobby because the ultimate sacrifice had to be made in order to free him. Harry has a connection to Dobby that stretches books. Who was not initially a target of the basilisk. But we do know that some of their magic will be detected when performed around young wizards and presumed to be known spells. ’ There was silence in the room. Why did Harry ask Dobby not to save him? Harry loves Dobby and knows his enemy is too strong and powerful, so harry is always a guy who is willing to take any danger and challenge even if he doesn’t care about his life, but at the same time he cares about the lives of others, so harry doesn’t want to engage some in risk. The Harry Potter franchise has had massive success, partly thanks to its heavy emphasis on friendship and family and the importance of maintaining those relationships. [1] On 1 September 1992, the house-elf Dobby used this charm to block the barrier to Platform Nine and Three-Quarters, therefore preventing Harry Potter and Ronald Weasley from using it, as part Why didn't Dumbledore get Harry himself, after Harry's parents died? Dumbledore was stronger than Hagrid, Hagrid had less skill. What did Lucius know if the diary? Why did Dobby assume it’s Harry? Dobby was also a very good, noble and selfless being. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet I doubt it would have mattered. Harry calls out for her to do something out of misplaced hope that Hermione will know something that can help Dobby. " Before Lily could hex James I drug Hermione over to the table where a bunch of sandwiches we collected from Kitchens earlier were. But Kreacher did not answer the summons. In deathly hallows, the scene where they were all escaping from Malfoy manor with Dobby’s help, and bellatrix throws a knife as they were disapparating, as they get to the cottage where Bill and Fleur were staying in, Harry discovers dobby was stabbed (I’ve always wondered why the knife didn’t get to the goblin instead, anyways) He’s frantically trying to save the little elf and looks As an infant, during the battle at the ministry, and at the battle of Hogwarts. Why did Dobby speak so highly of Dumbldore to Harry on their first meeting and why did he think so highly of Harry? I ask why he chose to break away and risk so much to warn Harry in the 2nd book. However, it was Dobby who did the magic. Not only did Dobby help Harry in gathering information throughout the series, but the elf also ended up saving Harry's life from an attack by Lucius in House Elf magic is woefully understudied. Don't they know who exactly Dobby was definitely infuriating during CoS, but by the end of that book/film, you find out he was desperately fighting against his master's commands to find any loophole to save Harry's life, so the annoying things he did at least Time for chapter twelve. Why couldn t they save Dobby with Magic? Also, Dobby’s injury was Why did Hermione not save Dobby? One could argue that Dobby is projecting his feelings onto Harry, which combines with his inability to speak freely about his concerns to Harry and results in a series of deeply ineffective attempts to keep Harry out of harm's way. Why didn't he prevent Sirius's conviction and suspect the explosion killing twelve Muggles was caused by Wormtail (and that Sirius cornered Wormtail instead of the other way around)? 1: Though in this thread it is said Dumbledore didn't know. It was Bellatrix who killed Dobby, she tried to kill Harry but she hit Dobby by throwing a dagger at him when he was apparating the three out of First save: He sent Dobby to Malfoy Manor to rescue Harry, Ron, and Hermione. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows I really loved Dobby at the end; but at first he infuriated me. Why did Hermione not help Dobby when he was dying? Originally Answered: Why didn’t Hermione help Dobby when his life was in danger in Deathly Hallows 1? She was in shock from being tortured by Bellatrix, if you remember from the books and movies she was really weak, she couldn’t do anything just witness the death happen of Dobby. Pushing Harry roughly aside, he knelt over Malfoy, drew his wand, and traced it over the deep wounds Harry’s curse had made, muttering an incantation that sounded almost Harry Potter's father, James, once saved Severus Snape's life. That's why the first thing he did after getting paid his make his God a pair of Dobby can only be freed if his masters present him with clothes, sir. Thanks to his Dobby’s selfless sacrifice in order to save Harry and his friends ultimately helps them in their fight against Voldemort. As the group escapes, Bellatrix throws her silver dagger and fatally wounds Dobby. Harry reveals that for the second task, he must find a way to breathe underwater for one hour and recover whatever the Merpeople have taken from him. Dobby was closer, but Harry had closure on his death. This is a Bill/Harry soul mate fic Dobby knew of the plan to reopen the Chamber of Secrets during Harry Potter's second year at Hogwarts. As for the Hover Charm, perhaps it was a wizard charm that Dobby learned from the Malfoys, and thus detectable. Seamus gave a great roar of delight and ran to hug his best friend. We all know that underage magic (performing it in the presence of a muggle is a additional charge) is against wizarding law. Hermione is not a medical witch. Dobby courageously returned to Malfoy Manor to rescue Harry and was mortally wounded. The loud crack, we know from elsewhere in the series, is due to Dobby's disapparition. Despite the Harry’s decision to give Dobby a sock was not only a selfless act of kindness but also a demonstration of his growing empathy and understanding of the wizarding world. Dobby was eventually killed by Bellatrix Lestrange. A psychiatrist forcibly restraining and sedating a manic patient who wants to hurl himself off a high ledge (because he thinks he can fly like Superman) is still trying to help the patient (by keeping him alive) even though the patient may disagree in his current (manic) "Why did Dobby cheat his master?" Because Proletariat has Nothing To Lose But Their Chains (Karl Marx (c)). When Harry heard the signature crack of apparition, he saw two elves fighting. In the course of trying to save Harry's life, Dobby did the following: He stole all of Harry's mail. I want to apologize to silo666. Dobby asks Harry if the rumors are true that he escaped Voldemort a second time. Harry hand-dug Dobby’s grave and, with his friends, tenderly clothed the elf’s body for burial. Throughout this scene, the situation is extremely tense and dangerous, with little opportunity for the characters to process what is happening. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. []’ This doesn't clearly tell me whether Stonewall High is a boarding school or not, but I don't see why it wouldn't be, given that Dudley is sent to one as well. And then he blocked the platform at kings cross and hit Harry with the bludger. “You can’t. Harry was always true to them he arguably never disrepair the boys he even gave dobby the sock to prank Malfoy Hermione went to hard but harry was always there saving the world and being a kind person. “The door banged open behind Harry and he looked up, terrified: Snape had burst into the room, his face livid. Much to Harry's hot-headed annoyance, Dobby caused untold amounts of chaos and mayhem during his multiple attempts at stopping Harry from returning to Hogwarts for his second year. The family is careful not to pass Dobby even a sock, sir, for then he would be free to leave their house forever. I always did wonder about that! The character Lucius would never ever dare to try and kill Harry at Hogwarts (though the film was created before GoF came out and all Jason Isaacs really knew was that Lucius was definitely not a friend of "Just Harry to my friends, Dobby," said Harry. Yet, if Lucius knows what it's for, we're back to I believe Dobby would answer if Harry called but I’m not sure if there must be an established master/servant relationship for this to work. Chapter 1 Discussion. In 1992, he disobeyed his masters and tried to warn Harry Potter of the plot to “Look,” Harry began, without knowing what he was going to say, but it did not matter: the tunnel door had just opened behind him. Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. Harry is not a killer. Dobby's not very bright. Also chapter 4, where Uncle Vernon says: ‘He's going to Stonewall High and he'll be grateful for it. Without Dobby’s bravery and willingness to put himself in danger, Harry and his friends may not have @AnthonyGrist Dobby was ultimately trying to help Harry (by keeping him safe from danger). That way, when Dumbledore comes to rescue him from it all, he's his hero and gets a willing In J. Lucius became angry and attempted to attack Harry, but Dobby blasted him down a flight of stairs. I always wondered why they never did this (aside from the fact that they are young and dumb and adventurous). but I love the scene where Harry says "Don't try to save my life again" and Dobby just smiles, that was so cute. Hermione was not an experienced healer. That dialogue tells us that Dumbledore talks to Aberforth about Harry. There may be people who noticed that it was blocked (muggle parents, wizards who used a car, etc. There's the possibility that Dobby knew house elves who worked at Hogwarts, who overheard where Harry lived from Dumbledore. Blocked Barrier[2] was a charm (incantation unknown) that could be used to seal magical barriers and portals of the like used by witches and wizards to limit access to magical locations. Kreacher, AND Dobby. Dobby was adamant that Harry should not return to Hogwarts and went as far as sealing the portal to platform 9 and 3/4 so it's not inconceivable that he would continue to try and prevent Harry's return to school after his first attempt failed. How come Kreacher came when Harry called but not when Sirius did? It seems that the characters in the story did not fully utilize all of their options in an effort to save Dobby, which has led some fans to criticize their actions. Weasley had sent, Dobby looked quite overwhelmed. Aberforth: Did he now? Easy job. When Dobby is at Privet drive stealing Harry 's letters, he notices how Harry is being "treated like a house -elf". " Dobby says they are careful never to “pass In Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets, Dobby tries to keep Harry out of school, and when that fails, Dobby tried to injure Harry so he would leave. It was no accident and only in the movie did Harry notice the book at all. New Best I'm not so sure that just because Lucius didn't know it was a horcrux that means Dobby didn't. What about Harry did he find different? I'm sure that Harry was not the first wizard that the Malfoy family chose to do harm to over the years. " Dobby says they are careful never to “pass Dobby even a sock,” indicating that it’s not handling a sock, but being given one that is problematic. When he found out about the possible death that could have resulted from malfoy's plan he went to the only good person he ever heard of, Harry Potter. He is also useful muscle - if they need to rescue Harry by force. A while ago, he asked if I could put Morgana Le Fay in this story. That‘s why they did not land directly at the house, which probably is a cottage. I imagine even if they managed to fix the wound with magic (none of Harry, Ron and Hermione are Healers, so they'd have to waste time getting a Healer), it'd probably But as soon as Harry forbade him to hurt himself, or tell Umbridge what was going on, Dobby was more than happy to obey - even though Harry didn't actually have a position of authority at Hogwarts. " Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Dobby using a Hover Charm in Not using Mundungus was also because he’s a literal piece of shit Well, I mean, Dobby was hit by a knife in the chest (iirc). I am 26 now and just realized that in Chamber of Secrets after Dobby’s many horrendous attempts to “save his life,” Harry asks Dobby to promise to never try to do so again and that Dobby’s last act of his own life is, in fact, successfully saving Harry Potter’s life. But just I did not say it's The Umbreakable Vow, I said it can be similiar. So he had to prepare a Plan for Harry's safety in case of an early death. Harry: We've been hunting horcruxes, we need you to get us into the castle. So he got in touch with Dobby - who was still working at Hogwarts - and told him to go and rescue everyone. They could have proven it was sealed (unless of course Dobby unsealed it). Snape never got to pay him back for that (in fact he did the opposite and he gave Voldemort the information that killed Lily and James In Chamber of Secrets, Dobby went to see Harry a couple of times (first at Privet Drive and then at Hogwarts Castle's Hospital Wing). W is all about improving the lives of house elves, so I feel like Hermione would want to know that she was inadvertently making Dobby’s life harder since none of the other house elves wanted to clean the Gryffindor common room anymore. There's a belief that Dobby broke a promise when he saved Harry Potter's life at Malfoy Manor, but that wasn't necessarily the case. It's Dobby's unique character and psychology that explains why he pops out of the blue and tries to save Harry from what he thinks is almost certain death. Harry is in danger four times in Chamber of Secrets: the Whomping Willow, the Rogue Bludger, escaping Aragog, and fighting the basilisk. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and I am 26 now and just realized that in Chamber of Secrets after Dobby’s many horrendous attempts to “save his life,” Harry asks Dobby to promise to never try to do so again and that Dobby’s last act of his own life is, in fact Why Dobby Helped Harry Potter in Chamber of SecretsHarry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets introduced Dobby as a complicated ally. Dobby apparates into the cellar and helps Harry and Ron rescue Hermione and the other prisoners. ” Black and Lupin both looked staggered. Dobby is trying to stop Harry from going back to Hogwarts, telling him that bad things are going to happen there. "Dobby will work hard for Harry Potter now he is Harry's elf friend," said Dobby. Possibly even people that were killed. He figured his own son was safe because he was a pureblood. He takes it upon himself to rescue Harry instead, and forms a house-elf team to do that. My question: How did Dobby know that Kreacher was apparating to Harry, and how the hell did he start fighting him mid-apparation? However, Snape and Dumbledore had a pact all along, intending to get Dumbledore killed so that Harry would run into Voldemort -madly- so Harry would get killed (Harry had to be killed so that Snape could kill Voldemort after, because Harry was the last Horcrux). If Dobby knows, Lucius knows. "I don't From all these cases, and from the fact the Ministry did not detect Dobby's apparation, it seems apparent to me that Wizards are in fact unable to prevent or detect House-Elf Apparation. He probably shouldn't have survived the few moments that he did. Crouch The consensus seems to be she doesn't actually know her knife killed Dobby specifically, but she assumes it would have hit someone (not that she would care to think any more about it). He knew that it had something do with Voldemort, and that Harry could have been in danger at Hogwarts. It seems it's main reason why Harry was "forced" to be part of The Triwizard Tournament. Another dialogue: Harry: Dumbledore has given us a job to do. his knowledge is accurate in that there’s danger but he is warning just Harry. Dobby's death does not only reflect the desire Harry's parents had to protect him but also echoes the death of Cedric Diggory in the Goblet of Fire. Harry believes in some way that he is responsible for Dobby. In Charms class, Harry, Ron, and Hermione are learning Banishing charms, the opposite of Summoning. She can’t heal Dobby. Nevertheless, it is clear that, after the events in Chamber of Secrets, Dobby would have enthusiastically entered Harry’s service. As if Harry didn't have enough trouble going on. House elves have a different kind of magic than wizards do and it wouldn't surprise me if they can sense magic in a different way as. Harry did not want anyone to put themselves in danger over him. Dobby rescues Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, and several other anti-Voldemort fighters from Malfoy Manor — just before Voldemort arrives — and whisks them away to a safe place. As I explained last chapter, Morgana It was no accident and only in the movie did Harry notice the book at all. But at the end of the Second book Harry asks Dobby to never save his life again. There was a loud crack, and Harry's fist was suddenly clenched on thin air. Dobby in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. He wanted to pay his respect and wished Dobby could have a funeral like Dumbledore. The last time Lucius saw Dobby was in 1998, when Dobby came to Malfoy Manor to rescue Harry Potter and his friends. Dobby’s favourite item of clothing is the sock after Harry freed him by conning Lucius Malfoy into throwing him one, which explains How did Dobby the house-elf intercept Harry's mail during Harry's summer holiday between Philosopher's Stone and Chamber of Secrets? ‘See what it’s like here?’ [Harry] said. Using the mirror he could see Harry was in danger. “You can’t kill him,” he said breathlessly. ), and they may be confused themselves, and instead sought an authority (a guard or someone similar) at Platform 9 3/4 as we (normal people behavior) do. Just like Kreacher sleeping a nest of moldy items, Dobby never knew what a bed actually was. Cedric, Ted, Tonks, Moody weren't super close to Harry. Presumably Dobby overheard Lucius talking about his plan to get rid of the incriminating diary & frame Mr. Harry did indeed run into Voldemort but when Voldemort casted the Killing Curse on Why did the Dursley family fight so hard to keep Harry in their care, be the time to send him to every magical child, so only as a final option. Also, Harry had a mega lack of common sense as a 12 year old. It is unknown how the Malfoys reacted when they learned of it. We just do not have enough informations about that, I can't go to theorize about what exactly contract is that. 493 “We got your message, Neville! Hello, you three, I thought you must be here!” It was Luna and Dean. Dobby was doing everything he was not told to do viz: Going out of house without permission; Meeting Harry without permission; Telling him few of the family secrets and warning him about the incidents within castle - all without permission So has JKR ever mentioned, or is it indicated anywhere in canon why Fawkes did not come to save Dumbledore when he was confronted by Draco and the four other Death Eaters on the Astronomy Tower on that fateful night in Chapter 27 of the Half-Blood Prince? There are several instances where Fawkes was timely in saving his master and Harry. DH: Harry had his retort ready for when they [Ron and Dean] asked him why he had not simply created a perfect grave with his wand, but he did not need it. Griphook seems to hold Harry in at least higher esteem than he would probably hold most wizards, commenting on Harry taking the Harry Potter had done every thing he could to save Dobby, now it was Dobby's turn. He caused the Dursleys to lock Harry in a room for the remainder of the summer (until he was rescued). This wasn't given an explanation for in the books. But Lucius likely did not know what was in the chamber, and of course he did not know the diary was a horcrux. Harry had fallen asleep in the library, where he was doing research trying to solve the egg’s 22 votes, 17 comments. He then tells Harry why he is there: he wants to warn Harry that he should not go back to Hogwarts, implying that there is a plot to make “most terrible things” happen this year. keeping a firm hold on Dobby's wrist to stop him from hitting himself with the water jug again. How did aberforth send Dobby? After Sirius’ death, his mirror came into the possession of Mundungus Fletcher, who sold it to Aberforth Dumbledore. Their lives were also turned upside down due to Harry when Voldemort was ‘defeated’. That Dobby chose to stay with them so that he could help Harry, and Hermione did not have the heart to upset the little fellow by mentioning her dislike of elf slavery. So he made a plan to warn and block his way to hogwarts. Kind of like you could tell someone to bring you to grimmauld place, but that would only drop you of on the street and not inside number 12. K. Why did Dobby stop Harry? Harry would have been in grave danger if he went to hogwarts. Wrapped in Harry’s coat, Dobby died at Shell Cottage, gazing solely upon his beloved redeemer, with Harry’s name on his reverent lips. [Harry Potter] Why did Dumbledore leave Harry with the Dursleys if he knew they were terrible people? We all dispossessed, and abused. He got Harry in trouble with the Ministry for using magic at home. The most I can think is that Hagrid (since he was part giant) would be immune to some spells, like he was immune to the stunning spells they shot at him in the 5th book. Who would make a evil plan to hurt harry by giving some kid that vaguely knows him some dark magic shit. When Harry says yes, Dobby remarks on how “valiant and bold” Harry is. In the book, Lucius didn't even put the book in the cauldron, he snuck it into her textbook and shoved it at Ginny sneering that used books were all her father could afford her so she better appreciate it. we know that dobby went to shell cottage because ron told him to, but we also learn that shell cottage is under the fidelius charm and bill is the secret keeper. He ran forward, placing himself in front of Pettigrew, facing the wands. If you mean when things were more quiet at Grimauld Place, wellKreacher finally came around, but him and Dobby don’t get along. Perhaps he thought nobody would think much if just Harry didn’t show up. Weasley, likely to Narcissa. fighting the Elf law of keeping family secrets (Chamber of secrets); helping with the second task of the Triwizard Tournament (Goblet of Fire) We see the bludger actively seek Harry and chase him while disregarding all other players and spectators. Imagine if they just waited for the Weasleys to get back to the other side of the platform. Dobby wakes Harry up ten minutes before the second task, tells him that he will have to rescue Ron, and gives him Gillyweed (GF26). Dobby thought he was doing what’s best to protect Harry. Along with Kreacher's actions in OoTP, this seems to indicate that elves can choose to interpret their orders as strictly or loosely as they wish. We know that he tampered with a Bludger so it would aim only for Harry, but Dobby tried several things to prevent Harry from returning to school. " "I'm actually not that hungry, in fact I think I might just go-" "Oh no you When Dobby helped Harry Potter and his friends escape from the Malfoy Manor. We know in GOF he knows Winky, so despite the unlikeliness that the Malfoy's invited Crouch over for tea, "You better not prank her, James Potter!" "Lily, love, you know I don't make promises I can't keep. Together, as said in the answer above, it was improper because of Harry's feelings towards Dobby, who while sometimes too much, cared for Harry's good. This did not happen when the letters were interrupted - so it either didn't happen at the Dursley's home, or if it did, it was too unlike any wizard spells for the Trace to detect it. 5M subscribers in the harrypotter community. The first two Dobby caused, and the second two he couldn't have predicted, so it's unclear what exactly Dobby is saving Harry from. People will tell you that he has a mistrust of adults, but that’s at odds with the implicit trust that he had for Dumbledore up until OotP. But in the end I loved Dobby. I said yes and I have. ‘See why I’ve got to go back to Hogwarts? It’s thethink Yeah, he saved Harry and co and died for it, but I wasn't upset at all when it happened. Harry discovers that the creature on his bed is a house-elf named Dobby. Why did Dumbledore allow Harry to take the Horcrux before he had fully examined it, especially as Dumbledore knew it was a Horcrux? The Peverell ring had a lethal curse placed on it for anyone who tried to put the ring on. P. Not when it had been her idea to use the normally happy little guy. "The left sock was bright red, and had a pattern of broomsticks upon it; the right sock was green, with a pattern of snitches. yes, ron had been there when he left harry and hermione, but that i’m Additionally, he did not know when exactly he would die. Dobby knows there is great danger yet only alerts Harry. When Dobby dies, it is a crushing loss to Harry. Dobby is a peculiar and emotional being; he bursts into tears when Harry offers him a seat and punishes himself when he speaks ill of the wizards he has encountered. Rowling's Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, chapter 10, we have Harry. It was so mean to withhold Harry's mail and he did the hover charm that caused Harry so much pain and anguish.